From After Effects to Flash
Author(s): Tiago Dias, Tom Green
Paperback: 504 pages
Publisher: friends of ED (December 11, 2006)
ISBN: 1590597486
Overall Score: 3/5
By now, everyone knows the great enhancements to working with video that Flash 8 brought with it. As someone who works closely with a motion animator in After Effects, I figured it’d be a great idea to check this book out and see what others are doing with it. I have to admit, I was sorely disappointed with what this book had to offer. To its credit, the book never did state that it was going to show me any groundbreaking After Effects stuff and how to leverage it in Flash to create a crazy, dynamic, animation driven website. However, when I think of the stuff that has been done with AE and Flash over the past year or two, I don’t really consider the awesomeness of the text animation and lens flares (Chapter 5) and exploding Flash text (Chapter 7).
There is much more to working with After Effects and Flash than things like this which were possible to do 5 years ago. I look at sites created by companies such as Big Spaceship and North Kingdom and always wonder, how did they do that. I know that they used video/After Effects for some of this stuff but I’m not quite sure how to wrap my head around the process of doing it since I’m not extremely familiar with AE and how to compress everything properly to bring into Flash for ease of use.
I’d like to see even something as simple as a particle system effect from AE used in a Flash button, which hundreds of sites are doing these days, or a particle system on a preloader (which always puzzles me since you have to keep the size of the preloader really small so that you don’t have to make a preloader for a preloader), but instead we get fed with some drivel about preset text effects in AE (Chapter 3) and masking videos (Chapter 9). That now makes a total of 3 chapters that are talking about text. I’m not sure about you, but I don’t spend a plethora of hours on each project trying to figure out how I want the text to animate in on an intro animation (one reason being that I very rarely ever create intro animations unless a client just flat out insists on having one, but still…).
This title would have been better served being labeled a Foundation title which friends of ED usually dishes out to introductory level books. It doesn’t have the pizzazz that I was hoping from a title this misleading and I would not recommend this book unless you are absolutely just starting out using video in Flash 8 and After Effects (although, if you’re a Flash guy, I’d suggest their other video title, Foundation Flash 8 Video, which could be the reason why this book didn’t get the Foundation stamp in the first place).